Butt Plugs

Picking the right butt plug

Size and insertable length

The numbers matter more than the label. A "medium" from one brand might be wider than a "large" from another — sizing isn't the same across different brands, so always check the insertable length and maximum diameter before buying. If you're newer to anal, start with a slim plug with a tapered tip and a narrow diameter. More experienced? There are plenty of wider, longer options here that go well beyond entry-level. Let the measurements guide you, not the name on the packaging.

Material and body safety

Silicone is the most popular material for anal plugs, and for good reason — it's non-porous, easy to sterilise, and pairs well with anal lube, which is a must for any anal toy since the body doesn't produce its own lubrication here. Anal-specific lubes tend to be thicker and longer-lasting than standard formulas, so they stay where you need them. You'll also find PVC plugs in the range, which tend to be softer and more flexible but are porous, so using a condom over the top keeps things hygienic. For something heavier with real weight behind it, stainless steel plugs and glass are both non-porous and temperature-responsive. What you go for comes down to how the plug feels inside you and how much aftercare you're happy with.

Base style and hands-free wear

Every anal plug here has a flared base — that's non-negotiable for safe anal use. But the base shape affects how you'll actually wear it. Suction cup bases lock onto smooth, flat surfaces for hands-free riding, which opens up a completely different way of using a plug. T-bar and round flared bases sit more naturally between the cheeks and feel better over longer periods. If you're planning to keep a plug in while doing other things, the base profile matters just as much as what's going inside.

Features that change how it feels

Not all butt plugs feel the same once they're in. A beaded shaft gives you that pop-and-release as each ridge passes through — completely different from a smooth plug that just slides in and sits. Weighted plugs with a rolling internal core move with your body, so you feel them shift without needing vibration or anything mechanical. Shape matters on entry too. A tapered tip eases in gradually, while a bulb head stretches you wider before the narrow neck pulls it into place. Have a think about what appeals to you most, then use the filters above to narrow it down.

Prostate-angled shapes

Some plugs in this range have angled or curved heads shaped to press against the P-spot. If prostate stimulation is the goal, look for a bulbous or curved tip rather than a straight taper — the angle makes all the difference. For a wider range of purpose-built prostate toys, our prostate massagers collection goes deeper into that category.

The appeal of butt plugs

A butt plug does something no other anal toy really does — it stays put. Slide it in, and it holds position on its own while your hands and attention go elsewhere. That's what makes them a go-to during foreplay, during sex, or just worn around the house to build anticipation before anything else happens. The passive fullness is the whole point, and nothing else delivers it the same way.

They're also one of the few anal toys that double as something visual. Jewel butt plugs sit flush with a decorative gem on the outside — popular during couples' nights or as part of a broader aesthetic. If you want adjustable stretch without swapping toys, inflatable butt plugs let you control the size in real time. And for anyone drawn to temperature play, a glass butt plug warmed or cooled before use adds something completely different.

How butt plugs compare to other anal toy types

Butt plugs are built to sit inside and stay there — that's the fundamental difference. Anal probes are shaped for thrusting and in-and-out movement. Anal beads work differently again — the feeling comes from pulling them in and out, bead by bead. If you want something you insert once and leave in place — during sex, foreplay, or extended wear — a plug is the right choice.

Not sure which type suits you? Think about how you plan to use it. Plugs reward patience and stillness. Probes and beads reward motion. Different goals, different tools.

Quality brands, discreet service

Every butt plug in this range comes from an established manufacturer — B-Vibe, California Exotic, Doc Johnson, NS Novelties, Toy Joy, and more. No unbranded imports, no mystery materials. Silicone products here are body-safe and non-porous, and every listing includes full measurements and material specs so you know exactly what you're ordering.

All orders ship in plain, unbranded packaging with no logos or product names visible. Same-day dispatch on orders placed before 2pm (Mon–Fri), and delivery is free when you spend over £50. If anything's not right, returns are straightforward and handled quickly.